Español
The word “petty” makes these charges sound harmless. They are not. A theft conviction in Florida is treated as a crime of dishonesty, a label that can shadow you every time an employer, landlord, or school runs a background check, long after any fine or jail time is behind you.
That is what makes even a small theft charge worth taking seriously. The immediate penalties matter, but the lasting mark on your character is often the part that does the real damage.
At Weldon Law Group, PLLC, our Jacksonville attorneys defend clients against theft charges across Northeast Florida. Attorney Ian Weldon spent more than a decade as a trial lawyer in the Jacksonville Public Defender’s Office, and he understands that a theft case is not just about property. It is about protecting your name.
Theft in Florida means knowingly taking someone else’s property with the intent to deprive them of it. Petty theft is not limited to shoplifting. It can also involve taking from an employer, from another person, or even attempting a theft without completing it.
Under Fla. Stat. §812.014, whether a theft is a minor misdemeanor or a felony comes down mostly to one thing: the value of the property.
Florida draws the line between petty theft and grand theft at $750. Anything below that is petit theft, a misdemeanor, and the value of the property sets the exact level.
Charge | Value of property | Classification | Maximum penalty |
Petit theft, second degree | Under $100 | Second-degree misdemeanor | Up to 60 days jail, $500 fine |
Petit theft, first degree | $100 to under $750 | First-degree misdemeanor | Up to 1 year jail, $1,000 fine |
Grand theft, third degree | $750 to under $20,000 | Third-degree felony | Up to 5 years’ prison, $5,000 fine |
One detail matters more than people expect: value is measured by the property’s fair market value at the time of the theft, not its original price tag. Showing that an item was worth less than the state claims can lower the charge, sometimes from a felony to a misdemeanor.
Most petty theft cases in Northeast Florida come out of stores, and retail theft has its own rules. You do not have to leave the store to be charged. Simply concealing merchandise, switching price tags, or tampering with packaging can be enough. Store security also has a limited legal right to detain someone they suspect of shoplifting, which is where many of these cases begin, and where they can also go wrong.
Here is what sets theft apart from many other misdemeanors of the same size. Because it is classified as a crime involving dishonesty, a conviction can be used to attack your credibility if you ever testify, and it raises an immediate red flag for anyone deciding whether to trust you.
That hits hardest where trust is the job. Positions in banking, retail, healthcare, and any role handling money or sensitive information often treat a theft conviction as disqualifying. A one-time mistake can quietly close doors in your career for years, which is exactly why keeping a conviction off your record is the central goal of the defense.
A theft conviction can also carry consequences that have nothing to do with jail or fines:
Contact us for more information about our services.
A petty theft charge does not always stay petty, and the jump to a felony can happen in ways that surprise people. The most important is your history: with two or more prior theft convictions, any new petty theft becomes a third-degree felony, no matter how small the value.
Two other situations can also push a case over the line. Prosecutors can aggregate several small thefts committed within a set period to reach the felony threshold, and theft from a dwelling can be charged as a felony even below the usual value. Recognizing when the state is reaching for a felony, and pushing back, is often the most important early work in these cases.
Many people accused of retail theft are startled to receive a letter demanding money from the store or its lawyers, separate from anything happening in criminal court. This is a civil demand under Fla. Stat. §772.11, which lets a theft victim seek damages well beyond the value of the item.
Two things are worth understanding. Ignoring the letter can lead to a separate civil lawsuit, but paying it does not make the criminal case go away. The two are entirely separate tracks, and a demand for payment is not a substitute for resolving the charge. Before responding to one of these letters, it is worth talking to a lawyer about how it fits with your criminal case.
A theft accusation is not a conviction, and these cases often have more weaknesses than they first appear. The right defense depends on the facts.
Theft requires a specific intent to deprive someone of their property, and the state has to prove it. Many strong defenses target that element or the value:
Other defenses focus on how the case was built:
Because the record is the lasting harm, much of the work in a theft case is aimed at avoiding a conviction entirely. For many first-time offenders, Florida’s pretrial intervention and diversion programs can lead to the charges being dismissed after the program is completed.
Where diversion is not available, a withhold of adjudication may avoid a formal conviction, and a case that ends without a conviction may later qualify for sealing or expungement. Protecting your future record is treated as part of the defense, not an afterthought.
A theft charge is really a fight over your reputation as much as your freedom. A conviction does not just carry a penalty; it attaches a label of dishonesty that can outlast the case itself, and it deserves a defense built around protecting both. We treat these charges as what they are for the person living through them: a threat to a job, a name, and a future that a single mistake should not define.
That is the approach we bring to every theft case:
Whatever led to the charge, our goal is the same: to protect your record, your name, and the future that depends on both.
Question | Answer |
If I give the item back, will the charges be dropped? | Usually not. Once a theft is complete, returning the property does not undo the crime, and the state can still prosecute. It may help in negotiations or at sentencing, but it does not automatically end the case. |
What if I forgot to scan an item at self-checkout? | It happens often, and intent is everything. Theft requires a deliberate intent to deprive the store, so a genuine mistake at self-checkout is not the same as shoplifting. These cases frequently come down to showing the act was an honest error, not a crime. |
What should I do if I am accused but did not take anything? | Stay calm and do not argue or explain at the scene, since anything you say can be used against you. Politely decline to answer questions, and contact a lawyer who can present your side the right way. |
Can a minor be charged with petty theft? | Yes. A teenager caught shoplifting is usually handled in the juvenile system, which focuses on rehabilitation and offers ways to avoid a lasting record. These cases call for a defense built around protecting a young person’s future. |
What if I only meant to borrow the item? | Intent is key, but “borrowing” is not always a defense. Florida law can treat even an intent to temporarily deprive an owner of their property as theft, depending on the circumstances, so these cases turn on the specific facts. |
How long does a petty theft case take to resolve? | It varies. A straightforward case handled through diversion or a plea can finish in a few months, while a contested case takes longer. Acting early often opens the fastest and most favorable paths. |
"*" indicates required fields
